top of page
Sundae Cake.jpg

Cakes

8" Round - 3 Layer Cake

Our signature 8-inch, three-layer cake is made from scratch with moist cake layers, delicious fillings, and smooth buttercream frosting. Perfect for birthdays, graduations, and special celebrations, this cake serves approximately 16–20 people and can be customized with your favorite flavors and designs.

Pricing start at $34.99

Sundae Cake.jpg
10" Round - 2 Layer Cake

Perfect for larger celebrations, our 10-inch, 2-layer cake features two layers of moist, made-from-scratch cake, filled and frosted with our signature buttercream. Beautifully decorated and customizable in your favorite flavors and colors, this cake is ideal for birthdays, graduations, showers, and special events. Serves approximately 20–30 guests.

Pricing starts at $39.99

Reeses Orig.jpg
Smash Cake

Make your little one's big milestone even sweeter with a custom smash cake! Perfectly sized for first birthdays and special photo moments, our smash cakes are made from scratch and decorated to match your celebration theme. Available in a variety of flavors and colors, these adorable cakes are designed for making memories—one messy bite at a time.

Pricing starts at $14.99

Smash Cake.jpg
1/4 Sheet Cake

Our 1/4 sheet cake is a crowd-pleasing choice for birthdays, office parties, graduations, and special gatherings. Made with soft, flavorful cake layers and finished with our signature buttercream frosting, each cake can be customized with your favorite flavors, colors, and designs. Serves approximately 20–30 guests and is perfect for sharing life's sweetest moments.

Pricing start at $34.99

Quarter Sheet Dino Cake_edited.jpg
1/2 Sheet Cake

Perfect for larger celebrations and events, our 1/2 sheet cake is made from scratch with moist cake and topped with our signature buttercream frosting. Fully customizable with your choice of flavors, colors, and decorations, this cake is ideal for birthdays, graduations, family gatherings, and corporate events. Generously sized to serve approximately 40–50 guests, it's a delicious centerpiece for any occasion.

Pricing starts at $49.99

Half Sheet Law and Mike.jpg
Full Sheet Cake

Designed to feed a crowd, our full sheet cake is the perfect choice for large celebrations and community events. Made from scratch with moist, flavorful cake and finished with our signature buttercream frosting, each cake can be customized with your favorite flavors, colors, and designs. Ideal for graduations, family reunions, company events, and other large gatherings, this cake serves approximately 80–100 guests and makes every occasion a little sweeter.

Pricing starts at $99.99

Full Sheet Graduation.jpg

Newsletter

Stay up to date with all the latest from Cookies & Cream Cafe

Thanks for submitting!

Hours

Monday: CLOSED

Tuesday: CLOSED

Wednesday: 6:30 am - 4:30 pm

Thursday: 6:30 am - 4:30 pm

Friday: 6:30 am - 4:30 pm

Saturday: 8:00 am - 1:00 pm

Sunday 8:00 am - 1:00 pm

Connect with us

(608) 396-3011

cookiescreamcafe@gmail.com

308 N Washington St

Melrose, WI 54642

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
bottom of page