top of page

    Cupcakes

The cupcakes in our bakery case are on a rotation, but we accept orders anytime!

This list isn’t exhaustive — if you’re looking for something else, just let us know! We’re happy to help!

Pricing starts at $25 per dozen.

Minimum 1 dozen per flavor.

Colorful Cupcakes Display

Birthday Cake

A light and fluffy vanilla cupcake bursting with rainbow sprinkles, crowned with a swirl of sweet buttercream and a shower of extra sprinkles — because every day deserves a celebration!

Chocolate 

Deep, fudgy chocolate cake crowned with a swirl of luscious chocolate buttercream — pure chocolate bliss in every bite.

Chocolate Mint

Decadent chocolate cake, topped with creamy mint frosting, a rich chocolate drizzle, and chocolate mint pieces — a perfect blend of chocolate and mint.

Dirt Cup

A rich chocolate cupcake filled with creamy chocolate pudding, swirled with crushed Oreo buttercream, sprinkled with Oreo crumbles, and topped with a classic Albanese gummy worm

Blueberry Lemon

A fluffy, zesty lemon cupcake filled with homemade blueberry compote, topped with a swirl of tangy lemon frosting — a fresh, fruity burst of flavor in every bite!

Chocolate Chip

A moist vanilla cupcake loaded with gooey chocolate chips, topped with vanilla buttercream and even more chocolate chips — a sweet, irresistible treat.

Cookie Butter

A rich, moist cupcake made with velvety cookie butter, filled with cookie butter and crowned with smooth cookie butter frosting and topped with a biscoff cookie for the ultimate indulgence.

Fudge Shortbread

Golden cake stuffed with warm fudge sauce, topped with fluffy chocolate buttercream, and sprinkled with sweet shortbread cookie crumbles for the perfect finishing touch.

Carrot Cake

A moist, spiced carrot cake cupcake topped with rich cream cheese frosting

and finished with a crunchy pecan — a perfect bite of cozy, classic flavor

with a little extra crunch!

Chocolate Covered Raspberry

A rich chocolate cupcake filled with homemade raspberry compote,

topped with smooth raspberry buttercream and finished with a drizzle

of glossy chocolate ganache for a decadent chocolate-berry finish.

Cookies & Cream

A soft, chocolate cupcake filled with creamy cookies and cream

filling, topped with a swirl of cookies and cream buttercream and a

sprinkle of crushed cookies — the ultimate treat for Oreo lovers!

German Chocolate

A rich, moist chocolate cupcake topped with a decadent coconut-pecan

frosting — a sweet, nutty treat that brings the classic German chocolate

cake flavor in a perfect cupcake form!

Lemon

A light, zesty lemon cupcake with a burst of citrus flavor, topped with smooth,

tangy lemon buttercream — a refreshing treat that’s perfect for any occasion!

Lemon Raspberry

A soft, citrusy lemon cupcake filled with rich raspberry compote and crowned with

tangy lemon buttercream — a perfect combination of sweet and tart.

Malted Milk Ball

​Vanilla cake loaded with malted milk ball bits, swirled with creamy vanilla

frosting, dusted in crunchy malted goodness, and crowned with a malted

milk ball for the perfect sweet finish

Monster Cookie Dough

A fun, indulgent cupcake filled with cookie dough, chocolate chips, M&Ms,

and a hint of peanut butter, topped with creamy frosting and even more

M&Ms — a monster of a treat for cookie dough and candy lovers!

Nutella

Chocolate cake stuffed with gooey Nutella fudge sauce, topped with

fluffy Nutella-chocolate buttercream and crowned with a Nutella truffle

for the ultimate chocolate-hazelnut treat

Orange Creamsicle

A light, fluffy orange cupcake topped with smooth orange buttercream —a

refreshing, citrusy treat that captures the nostalgic flavors of an orange creamsicle!

Peanut Butter Cup

A rich chocolate cupcake filled with creamy peanut butter, topped with smooth peanut

butter frosting and a mini peanut butter cup — a decadent treat that combines the best

of chocolate and peanut butter in every bite!

Pistachio

A soft, homemade pistachio pudding cupcake topped with smooth pistachio buttercream

and finished with a sprinkle of crushed salted pistachios.

Raspberry Dream

A light, fluffy vanilla bean cupcake filled with sweet raspberry compote, topped with creamy

raspberry buttercream — a dreamy, fruity treat that’s bursting with fresh raspberry flavor in

every bite!

Red Velvet

A soft, classic red velvet cupcake, topped with smooth, creamy cream cheese frosting — a rich and

elegant treat that’s timelessly delicious.

S'mores

A soft chocolate cupcake, filled with marshmallow fluff and topped with buttercream, toasted marshmallow, graham cracker and chocolate — a campfire favorite made for cupcake lovers!

Salted Caramel

A soft vanilla cupcake with a gooey caramel center, crowned with silky caramel frosting and finished with a touch of sea salt — the ultimate sweet and salty treat.

Strawberry

A tender strawberry cupcake filled with homemade strawberry compote and crowned with rich strawberry buttercream — a luscious, berry-packed delight.

Twix

Chocolate cake meets cookie-caramel crunch! This cupcake is swirled with vanilla frosting loaded with Twix pieces, then crowned with more Twix, chocolate ganache, and a caramel drizzle

Turtle

A rich chocolate cupcake filled with gooey caramel, topped with creamy chocolate frosting, a drizzle of caramel, and a sprinkle of toasted pecans — a decadent treat inspired by the classic candy!

Vanilla

A soft, fluffy vanilla cupcake topped with smooth, creamy vanilla buttercream — a timeless classic that's sweet, simple, and always delicious!

Wedding Cake

A soft, almond-flavored vanilla cupcake topped with silky vanilla-almond buttercream — an elegant, classic treat that's sweet, delicate, and perfect for any celebration!

Yellow

A moist, golden yellow cupcake crowned with smooth and creamy chocolate buttercream — a perfect balance of rich chocolate and light, fluffy vanilla in every bite.

Newsletter

Stay up to date with all the latest from Cookies & Cream Cafe

Thanks for submitting!

Hours

Monday: CLOSED

Tuesday: CLOSED

Wednesday: 6:30 am - 4:30 pm

Thursday: 6:30 am - 4:30 pm

Friday: 6:30 am - 4:30 pm

Saturday: 8:00 am - 1:00 pm

Sunday 8:00 am - 1:00 pm

Connect with us

(608) 396-3011

cookiescreamcafe@gmail.com

308 N Washington St

Melrose, WI 54642

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
bottom of page